Apple Granted Design Patent on CoverFlow

Apr 08, 2010

Media player programs that bear a "substantially similar" appearance are subject to change

The United States Patent and Trade Office awarded Apple with a range of patents including their patents for the MacBook Air superdrive and video-encoding system used in iChat, all of which pretty standard. But the patent to take note in the open source community is a design patent for CoverFlow, the visual way users parse through music and video on the iPod Touch, iPhone, iPad and in iTunes.

A design patent differs from a utility patent because it covers the appearance of an intellectual property, not how the property itself functions. In other words, any program that looks "substantially similar" to CoverFlow is eligible for legal action.

Programs and devices affected by the patent include Cover Flow, a similarly named (note the space) open source Flash script, MediaFlow, an add-on to Songbird and a variety of media players on mobile devices, such as the Motorola Droid, Nokia N900, Nokia Symbian^3, should Apple decide said interfaces are too similar.

CoverFlow was developed by Steel Skies and bought by Apple in 2006. As of this writing, Apple has not pursued legal action.

Related content

  • Google Addresses Concerns over WebM License

    Open source codec license gets tweaked in lieu of community concerns.

  • The State of Flash

    Apple, Microsoft, Opera and now Scribd have all spoken out about Adobe's platform. What does this mean for open source?

  • Google Reveals the WebM Project

    Project to create high-quality open standard for video on the Web based on Vorbis and VP8.

  • Defensive Patent License Shields Against Infringement Suits

    UC Berkeley professors devise a way to protect FOSS developers

  • Welcome

    Patent law is a very imperfect tool for establishing moral culpability. Whether you favor patents or not, it is important to face the fact that patent law is a construct of the business world. Patents protect opportunities for patent holders and restrict opportunities for others – all for some supposedly greater purpose, we are told, but in any case, none of this ever has the clarity that will allow you to point your finger at a violator as you would at someone who stole your car. So I don’t have a lot of faith in patents, but I still have a feeling you’ll do better in life if you come up with your own solutions.


  • Re:


    Under the design patent pretty much any interface that appears substantially similar to CoverFlow can be subject to a patent infringement claim, but filing a claim is up to Apple's discretion.
  • The other Apple OS applications

    One can use cover flow animations in any Apple OS application if he/she uses Cocoa. Indeed, Xcode has a widget for this purpose. Does this conflict with this new interesting patent?
comments powered by Disqus

Issue 43_SI: LibreOffice Expert/Special Editions

Buy this issue as a PDF

Digital Issue: Price $15.99
(incl. VAT)