Borg Reorg

Borg Reorg

Article from Issue 225/2019
Author(s): , Author(s):


Dear Reader,

Microsoft just announced that its built-in Linux kernel is available for testing. The Linux kernel that will be integrated with Windows 10 is tuned to work with the Windows Subsystem for Linux compatibility suite. Predictably, a new round of alarms went up around the Linux community – just as they did when Microsoft announced that they would soon be shipping this new Linux back in May. Microsoft distributing Linux? Is this a trick or some kind of nefarious subterfuge? Weren't they the ones who said Linux is a cancer?

The company now says they are quite friendly and happy with Linux, but their past behavior was so outrageous that many who remember the bad old days are still a bit spooked by their change of heart.

Microsoft used to prowl the headlines with a very intimidating aura of invincibility. The popular notion was that, whenever they wanted something, they got it. Starting with taking down IBM for dominance in the PC space, through the browser wars, through the office software wars, and on into countless other skirmishes, the Redmond raiders were known for using the power of their market position to overwhelm and destroy opposition, conjuring up comparisons with the Star Trek Borg and their menacing motto "resistance is futile." This image of indomitability was a tool in their arsenal that played quite well with users, venture capitalists, and government regulators and became a sort of self-fulfilling prophecy, which made matters worse.

When they declared Linux was their enemy, it was all very freaky for a while as they played through their various monopolistic power tricks, such as false information, lawsuits, and half-baked "patent indemnity" gambits. Many are wondering if they have truly given up on all the funny business.

But does it even matter anymore? Even if you don't trust that Microsoft has changed, you would have to agree that whatever it is they were trying to do back then doesn't seem to be working very well anymore.

Microsoft's recent record as a monopolist isn't exactly flattering. In fact, the whole reason they are working with Linux now is because their grand design to destroy Linux totally failed. Their grand plan to shoehorn themselves into the mobile phone space didn't just fail but failed spectacularly.

Microsoft is a player in today's web economy, but they are not even the biggest or most intimidating player. Their Bing search engine is a very distant number two in search engines with around 10 percent of the market share. Their Azure cloud appears stable but isn't exactly knocking down all the top competitors. (By the way, Azure is populated with lots of Linux systems at this point.)

I'm not sure you could say Microsoft has actually reformed in some cosmic sense, but I think the people who are afraid of them co-opting and subjugating Linux are giving them way too much credit.

Microsoft is not a power player in the Linux space, because, well, they don't want to be – and they won't want to be until they finally give up on selling Windows. And the tools they have used for control in the past (marketing hype, intellectual property threats) are not especially effective in the Linux community.

They'll hang around for a while. Maybe they will fit in and stay, or maybe they will get voted off the island. Somehow I don't see them as the last one standing.

Buy this article as PDF

Express-Checkout as PDF
Price $2.95
(incl. VAT)

Buy Linux Magazine

Get it on Google Play

US / Canada

Get it on Google Play

UK / Australia

Related content

  • Welcome

    Sometimes I'm amazed at how this column just slips out into the world and no one says much about it. One thing I do hear occasionally is that "It's refreshing that you aren't just summarizing the contents of the issue, which is what most welcome columns do." I do plead guilty to having a great many opinions, some of which I manage to share from time to time in this space. However, in this case, my opinion does point to an article you'll see in this month's issue.

  • Welcome

    The past few years have seen some encouraging signs from Microsoft. For instance, they no longer propagate transparent and self-serving falsehoods about Linux at every opportunity. However, recent events indicate that maybe the new Microsoft might be all too much like the old Microsoft.

  • Welcome

    A couple of insightful commentaries in this issue are already covering the news that Microsoft is joining the Linux Foundation (see Simon Phipps and Andrew Gregory inside). Since this column is the last to get written – usually right before we go to print, I'm really supposed to talk about things that aren't already covered in the issue, but this really is big news.

  • Welcome

    This article went to press one week before Richard Stallman abruptly resigned as head of the Free Software Foundation. Yikes! All is flux in the FOSS world. Still, the trend toward détente between Microsoft and the Free Software community is bound to continue, and these thoughts on Stallman’s recent visit to Redmond offer a glimpse into how real change happens – one small step at a time.

  • Welcome

    One of my memorable moments as a homeowner was looking out the window at a pair of neighborhood kids in my backyard, who were immersed in some sort of water fight. Never mind that my own kids weren’t with them, or that they didn’t have any kind of permission to be in my backyard – I’ll save those topics for the child-rearing magazines. In this case, the fight itself was what I most remember.

comments powered by Disqus