Linux From Scratch Drops SysVinit Support
LFS will no longer support SysVinit.
Linux From Scratch (LFS), along with its followup Beyond Linux From Scratch (BLFS), was one of the few projects that still offered SysVinit system support, but both are now abandoning SysVinit in favor of systemd.
In a recent post to a Linux From Scratch forum, Bruce Dubbs declared, "There are two reasons for this decision. The first reason is workload. No one working on LFS is paid. We rely completely on volunteers. In LFS, there are 88 packages. In BLFS, there are over 1,000. The volume of changes from upstream is overwhelming the editors." Dubbs continues, "In this release cycle that started on the 1st of September until now, there have been 70 commits to LFS and 1,155 commits to BLFS (and counting). When making package updates, many packages need to be checked for both System V and systemd. When preparing for release, all packages need to be checked for each init system."
In other words, there's just too much work involved to keep three different init packages for LFS.
Rightfully so, Dubbs also mentions that both KDE and Gnome are starting to build requirements that depend on features from systemd (such as the new Plasma login tool).
In the future, the LFS/BLFS 12.4 System V books will continue to be available. For the most part, newer versions of packages in those books will be able to be built with the instructions from there, but will not be tested by the LFS editors.
Potentially, this could be the end of SysVinit for all independent distributions, until the developers of those distributions take the time to build SysVinit into their systems without the help of LFS. Since systemd has become the de facto standard for the overwhelming majority of distributions, this decision makes sense on paper. Of course, there will be those who claim LFS has made the wrong decision.
Subscribe to our Linux Newsletters
Find Linux and Open Source Jobs
Subscribe to our ADMIN Newsletters
Support Our Work
Linux Magazine content is made possible with support from readers like you. Please consider contributing when you’ve found an article to be beneficial.
News
-
Linux From Scratch Drops SysVinit Support
LFS will no longer support SysVinit.
-
LibreOffice 26.2 Now Available
With new features, improvements, and bug fixes, LibreOffice 26.2 delivers a modern, polished office suite without compromise.
-
Linux Kernel Project Releases Project Continuity Document
What happens to Linux when there's no Linus? It's a question many of us have asked over the years, and it seems it's also on the minds of the Linux kernel project.
-
Mecha Systems Introduces Linux Handheld
Mecha Systems has revealed its Mecha Comet, a new handheld computer powered by – you guessed it – Linux.
-
MX Linux 25.1 Features Dual Init System ISO
The latest release of MX Linux caters to lovers of two different init systems and even offers instructions on how to transition.
-
Photoshop on Linux?
A developer has patched Wine so that it'll run specific versions of Photoshop that depend on Adobe Creative Cloud.
-
Linux Mint 22.3 Now Available with New Tools
Linux Mint 22.3 has been released with a pair of new tools for system admins and some pretty cool new features.
-
New Linux Malware Targets Cloud-Based Linux Installations
VoidLink, a new Linux malware, should be of real concern because of its stealth and customization.
-
Say Goodbye to Middle-Mouse Paste
Both Gnome and Firefox have proposed getting rid of a long-time favorite Linux feature.
-
Manjaro 26.0 Primary Desktop Environments Default to Wayland
If you want to stick with X.Org, you'll be limited to the desktop environments you can choose.
