Fast-Tracking Speech Recognition
Open Speech Initiative seeks to bring advanced speech processing to free software.
Over the years, free software has seen at least a dozen projects to implement speech recognition. However, even the most advanced of these projects, such as CMU Sphinx and Festival , often lag behind commercial equivalents, largely because of a lack of resources. To close this gap, Peter Grasch, a KDE developer from Austria, launched the Open Speech Initiative  in October 2013 with the goal of assembling "a team of developers looking to bring first class speech processing to the world of free software."
This is an ambitious project, but Grasch argues strongly for its importance.
"Speech recognition," he says, "is a greatly underutilized input method. Over the recent years we can at last see it slowly being adopted in mobile applications, and I think this trend will surely continue. I am not saying it can or will replace the other input methods we have now, but there are many use cases where speech input can simplify things. At least, after the first Iron Man movie came out, I think many would agree," Grasch adds, referring to the extensive speech processing capabilities that the movie's protagonist has embedded throughout his home and office as well as in his combat suit.
Given the growing importance of speech recognition, Grasch describes as "troubling" the fact that "speech technology was and to a large extent still is entirely in the domain of big business." Not only are the three main commercial developers – Nuance, Microsoft, and Google – proprietary, but so are the implementations for Android and Tizen.
According to Grasch, the reason for this situation is that "speech recognition requires significant upfront investment to acquire the necessary data, and tedious speech modeling that does not generalize well across languages – requiring countless more hours if you intend to support multiple languages." The result is a combination of resources, expertise, and effort that is extremely difficult to organize and sustain in a volunteer project.
However, Grasch suggests that such obstacles are beginning to become less important because of crowd-sourcing and the gradual accumulation of existing data. Now, he suggests, "with community engagement, we can build more accurate speech recognition systems and create better integrated solutions for more devices – and the use cases are truly endless."
Since 2010, Grasch has been explaining this rationale at conferences , including KDE's annual Akademy and the Desktop Linux Summit, as well as writing about it in academic papers. Now, with the Open Speech Initiative, he plans to put the rationale into practice.
The Path to Open Speech Initiative
Grasch became interested in free software while still in high school. "I was always a tech enthusiast and had been following the Linux movement with a bit of interest for some time when, in the tenth grade, I managed to thoroughly wipe my Windows installation from my home computer," he recalls. "At that point, I had never even tried a Live CD, but, for some reason, I decided to just install SUSE 9.3 instead of going back to XP. Since then, I have not owned a single Windows system."
The transition was not always smooth, but in getting his system up and running, Grasch discovered that he enjoyed both hacking and the community he discovered in the Linux forums. "While I had already dabbled in writing small programs back on Windows, I never realized that merely writing code is just the start of it; I wanted to become part of the free software community and give back," he says. His opportunity to get involved came about a year later, in a class in which students worked on projects suggested by professionals. When Franz Stieger, a special needs teacher, wanted to study the best speech recognition software for children with speech impediments, Grasch and three other students volunteered.
Grasch remembers, "We quickly realized that there was no commercial offering that was flexible enough to cope with non-standard speech patterns. So we drafted the concept of Simon, an extremely flexible open speech recognition system and set to work. To us, it was always clear that the result would be free software."
At the 2013 Akademy, the annual meeting of KDE developers, Grasch delivered a talk  in which he described the progress he was able to make on one challenge in speech processing in one week, using only free software data and technologies.
"The point," Grasch said, "was to show off how close – or, indeed, far away – we were from being able to implement current and next gen speech recognition using free software. The experiment was a big success and proved that by even just investing a handful of days, it was possible to further the state of the art in open source speech recognition."
Grasch continues, "A large part of the reason for conducting such an experiment was to show interested third parties that investing time in free speech technology is viable. Quite a few enthusiasts and even companies responded and showed interest. As a response, we set up the Open Speech Initiative both to give our newly formed team a common label and to formalize the cooperation."
The Open Speech Initiative is still in its earliest stages of development – so early that the website  is still under construction, and the project lists only half a dozen members.
"From a consumer perspective, there is little to see at this point," Grasch admits. "But behind the largely desolate end user software landscape for anything but command and control applications, there are some promising efforts. Grasch singles out CMU Sphinx for "mature speech recognition engines for a variety of use cases" and the KALDI toolkit , which he describes as "working on state of the art neural-network-based decoding.
However, the main challenge is to develop an efficient speech model, which is necessary to teach the recognition software what each language sounds like. "Creating such speech models requires careful and painfully time-consuming planning and tons and tons of data," Grasch explains. "Because of this, even projects using open source speech recognition engines mostly rely on proprietary speech models. This is why creating high quality open source speech models is on the forefront of the Open Speech Initiative's agenda."
Given this background, the immediate goals of the Open Speech Initiative are well-defined, particularly for Grasch's continued work on Simon. As described on Grasch's blog , much of this work is a necessary prelude to providing speech recognition – such as reviewing existing resources and working to improve acoustic and language models, as well as dictation capabilities . The ideal is "to create systems that aid with this and automate the process as much as possible," according to Grasch.
Eventually, the Open Speech Initiative intends to create the infrastructure to allow contributions from non-experts – perhaps even end users. Then, Grasch himself plans to add the missing features in Simon to produce a preview version that may be ready as early as this summer.
Even when these goals are reached, Grasch sees "a large, continuous effort" ahead, with no immediate end in sight. However, with the coordination of effort and the successful attracting of casual contributors, the Open Speech Initiative may represent the best chance for free software speech processing to catch the proprietary leaders in the field – and perhaps even show them a thing or two.
- CMU Sphinx: http://cmusphinx.sourceforge.net/
- Festival: http://www.cstr.ed.ac.uk/projects/festival/
- Open Speech Initiative launch: http://grasch.net/node/24
- Open Speech Initiative at KDE: http://speech.kde.org/
- Simon: http://simon.kde.org/
- Julius: http://julius.sourceforge.jp/en_index.php
- HTK: http://htk.eng.cam.ac.uk/
- Grasch at 2013 Akademy: http://files.kde.org/akademy/2013/videos/Peter_Grasch_-_FLOSS_Speach_Recognition.webm
- KALDI toolkit: http://kaldi.sourceforge.net/about.html
- Peter Grasch's blog: http://grasch.net/
- Dictation system: http://grasch.net/node/22 @IE
Buy this article as PDF
Kernel king admits his tone has alienated volunteers, but says the demands of the process require directness.
New flaw in an old encryption scheme leaves the experts scrambling to disable SSL 3
Lennart Poettering wants to change the way Linux developers talk to each other.
Enterprise giant frees itself from ink and home PCs (and visa versa).
Mozilla’s product think tank sinks silently into history.
TODO group will focus on open source tools in large-scale environments.
New tool will look like GParted but support a wider range of storage technologies.
New public key pinning feature will help prevent man-in-the-middle attacks.
Carnegie Mellon researchers say 3 million pages could fall down the phishing hole in the next year.
The US government rolls new best-practice rules for protecting SSH.