Fedora Project Board Starts into 2010
The project chair has appointed Red Hat employee Colin Walters to the board. John Poelstra begins the year with open feedback to the board's work.
With Red Hat developer Colin Walters, the last open position on the Fedora board has been filled. John Poelstra, who was appointed to the board by chair Paul Frields in June of 2009, nevertheless regretted in his blog the less than enthusiastic participation of the board. Halfway through his term, he writes, he wanted to evaluate its accomplishments. The two big themes were the Fedora trademark (as we reported) and the question of Fedora's mission, vision and target audience. Poelstra opened the discussion on the board mailing list in October 2009 after the issues apparently emerged in a board meeting shortly before.
The question "What is Fedora?" resulted in a number of responses, but Poelstra was disappointed that only half the board participated in the discussion and their regular conference calls showed only minimal interest in the issue. He hoped for a stronger leadership from board: "This isn't to say these ideas and leadership can't come from others in Fedora. It is great when they do. Ultimately though, the Fedora Board is accountable for providing a vision for the future [...] It is what we have been appointed or elected to do."
The Fedora board membership consists of five elected and four appointed members recommended by Red Hat and decided upon by the chair, who also has veto power. The last election took place in December 2009, when Chris Tyler and Matt Domsch were reelected. Appointed member Christopher Aillon's term was also extended for another year at the same time.
Interestingly the project released a questionnaire with some fanfare at the time of the December elections to help voting members decide. In other ways the history of the board leaves the impression that Red Hat is continuing to recruit from within. Tyler and Aillon were both previous members. Eight of the nine board members are Red Hat coworkers, with Tyler, as Canadian professor, the only exception.
Comments
comments powered by DisqusSubscribe to our Linux Newsletters
Find Linux and Open Source Jobs
Subscribe to our ADMIN Newsletters
Support Our Work
Linux Magazine content is made possible with support from readers like you. Please consider contributing when you’ve found an article to be beneficial.

News
-
System76 Releases COSMIC Alpha 7
With scores of bug fixes and a really cool workspaces feature, COSMIC is looking to soon migrate from alpha to beta.
-
OpenMandriva Lx 6.0 Available for Installation
The latest release of OpenMandriva has arrived with a new kernel, an updated Plasma desktop, and a server edition.
-
TrueNAS 25.04 Arrives with Thousands of Changes
One of the most popular Linux-based NAS solutions has rolled out the latest edition, based on Ubuntu 25.04.
-
Fedora 42 Available with Two New Spins
The latest release from the Fedora Project includes the usual updates, a new kernel, an official KDE Plasma spin, and a new System76 spin.
-
So Long, ArcoLinux
The ArcoLinux distribution is the latest Linux distribution to shut down.
-
What Open Source Pros Look for in a Job Role
Learn what professionals in technical and non-technical roles say is most important when seeking a new position.
-
Asahi Linux Runs into Issues with M4 Support
Due to Apple Silicon changes, the Asahi Linux project is at odds with adding support for the M4 chips.
-
Plasma 6.3.4 Now Available
Although not a major release, Plasma 6.3.4 does fix some bugs and offer a subtle change for the Plasma sidebar.
-
Linux Kernel 6.15 First Release Candidate Now Available
Linux Torvalds has announced that the release candidate for the final release of the Linux 6.15 series is now available.
-
Akamai Will Host kernel.org
The organization dedicated to cloud-based solutions has agreed to host kernel.org to deliver long-term stability for the development team.
Re
"Currently, six -- not eight -- out of nine members of the Board are Red Hat employees who are members of the Fedora community."
Thank you for your correction (I indeed seem to have misread the backround of Matt Domsch and Josh Boyer). As well, your additional details of how the Fedora board works are most welcome.
Best,
Anika
Clarifications and corrections
Currently, six -- not eight -- out of nine members of the Board are Red Hat employees who are members of the Fedora community. Chris Tyler, Matt Domsch, and Josh Boyer are all volunteer members of the Fedora community. These facts are shown prominently in the Board's membership wiki page which the article references, but then fails to indicate properly:
http://fedoraproject.org/wiki/Board#Members
Five seats on the Board are elected by the community, and four seats are appointed by the Fedora Project Leader. (Before I assumed the project leadership, the split went the other way.) Roughly half these seats turn over after each release of Fedora, approximately every six months. Therefore it's inaccurate to say that Red Hat is stacking the Board with Red Hat employees. The Fedora Project Leader makes appointments to the Board to include people who can bring their backgrounds, skills, and experience to help lead Fedora, regardless of their place of employment.
In the past, volunteer Fedora contributors have been appointed, just as the community sometimes elects Red Hat employee Fedora contributors. For instance, in the second previous election in June 2009, the Fedora community elected Red Hat employees to three Board seats -- Dennis Gilmore, Mike McGrath, and Tom Callaway -- while volunteer Josh Boyer was appointed. It is also interesting to note that the current project leader and Board chair is a former volunteer as well.
The article also doesn't take into account the fact that many Red Hat employees are involved with upstream projects as core contributors. Core contributors to upstream projects like Colin Walters, a long time contributor to the GNOME Project, bring significant insight and experience to the Board that's more relevant to their qualifications than where they happen to draw a paycheck. These traits are important to moving forward on broad and difficult issues such as the topics of mission, vision and target audience that opened significantly before John Poelstra's thoughtful October 2009 email. Work on these topics is reflected in the public archives of our minutes, notes, and mailing list starting in January 2009.
I encourage the author and editors to contact me and the Fedora Project Board if they are interested in any further clarifications or interviews. Thank you.