KDE for People Initiative Calls for AI Ban in Plasma
A new community of KDE wants the project to adopt a strict no-AI policy for KDE Plasma.
The KDE project has found itself in the middle of a small uproar over the use of AI. So much so, that a new community has risen called KDE for People. The community shares the same stance as KDE Eco, which states, "Given its extremely high energy and water consumption, the increased minimum system requirements driving premature hardware obsolescence, among other very problematic social and political issues, gen AI/LLMs are not compatible with the values and goals of KDE Eco."
For those who don't know, KDE Eco is a community initiative that was launched in 2021 to "measure, optimize, and certify the energy and resource efficiency of Free and Open Source Software."
KDE for People wants nothing short of a ban on generative AI in Plasma and all Plasma components. The project wants the ban to be founded on a pro-people outlook toward community, ethics, and the work that has gone into KDE software for decades. KDE for People also points to other projects that have taken similar stances against AI, such as Zig, elementary OS, and OBS Studio, stating that using AI erodes trust, makes code review more of a challenge, and harms privacy.
It should be noted that the proposed AI policy that was originally issued on invent.kde.org has been taken down.
As to the proposed ban, KDE for People believes the ban should include, "outputs of generative AI tools in code and assets, as well as using it for MR descriptions, issues or translation (e.g., the .po files). Related community spaces should also be considered, to avoid Vibe-Coding, the introduction of AI topics into Akademy and KDE Planet, and more normalization of this practice in the KDE Community."
Subscribe to our Linux Newsletters
Find Linux and Open Source Jobs
Subscribe to our ADMIN Newsletters
Support Our Work
Linux Magazine content is made possible with support from readers like you. Please consider contributing when you’ve found an article to be beneficial.
News
-
Linux 7.4 is "Much Healthier" Thanks to AI
At nearly 42 million lines, Linux 7.4 is the largest merge in the kernel’s history.
-
Working Exploit for a Linux Kernel Flaw Made Public
Even before a bug received its CVE identifier or an upstream fix, the local privilege escalation vulnerability exploit found its way into the wild.
-
r/opensource Bans AI-Assisted and AI-Related Projects
The de facto subreddit for all things open source has not only banned AI-related projects but also users who "don't speak English."
-
Bottlenecks Discovered by Meta Engineers Lead to Scalability Improvements
Thanks to a small group of engineers at Meta, the Linux kernel module kernfs has been improved, which has led to some serious gains.
-
PwnEscape Poses VM Vulnerability
A guest-to-host escape flaw in Linux KVM, named PwnEscape, might be yet another means of attacking Linux.
-
Linux Mint 27 Set for a Christmas Release
The developers behind Linux Mint have announced a Christmas release, and it looks like Santa's sack will be brimming with features.
-
Is Linus Torvalds Vibe Coding?
The creator of Linux has added AI into his process for Linux kernel development, and it's more than just for debugging.
-
openKylin 3.0 Released with Expanded AI Integration
The latest release features a pre-installed AI agent to help perform tasks.
-
DigitalOcean Ends Open Source Credits Program
In a change that has surprised many open source developers, DigitalOcean has decided to sunset its Open Source Credits Program.
-
Office 365 Available for Testing on Linux via Bottles
Linux users can now test the official Office 365, thanks to Mirko Brombin's work on Bottles.