How GNOME and KDE spend their money
Off the Beat: Bruce Byfield's Blog
Quarterly reports are the stuff of business. In most people's minds, they are as far from the spirit of free and open source software (FOSS) as anyone can imagine. All the same, as non-profit organizations, many FOSS projects issue them. And while your first reaction may be to avoid quarterly reports, they can give some insights into projects, especially if you read between the lines.
For instance, if you have been assuming, as I have, that GNOME has more corporate support than KDE, and a larger budget, a look at the latest report for GNOME and KDE may surprise you. Together, the two reports give an entirely different impression than you might assume.
Neither quarterly report has much in common with the glossy publications offered by multi-national publications. Both are PDF files with undistinguished layouts and a minimum of graphics. Even head shots of people mentioned or reporting are absent. Compared to corporate reports, those of both GNOME and KDE are practical, unadorned publications.
Of the two, GNOME's (its first, covering June, July, and August 2009) comes closest to the spirit of a corporate report. It includes not only the obligatory message from GNOME's executive director, but also reports from the Release, Bugsquad, Marketing, Web, Usability, Accessibility, Documentation, Art and Localizations Teams. Although some of these reports were outdated by the time the report was released, their overall impression is of a multi-tiered multi-national's executives reporting in. In general, the report fits in well with GNOME's traditional tendency to favor the corporate side and with its recent interest in marketing. Like most quarterly reports, it is as much a public relations document as an effort to provide concrete information (although it does both). The one non-corporate note is at the beginning, when executive director Stormy Peters asks readers, "please let us know if you find it useful!"
In comparison, KDE's report for March through June 2009 is less than one quarter the size of GNOME's. Although it includes the usual redundant introduction -- this time by Aaron Seigo -- it contains far fewer individual summaries than GNOME's report. These differences may reflect the greater experience that KDE e.V. -- the German non-profit that manages KDE -- has with the whole idea of reports, and has the advantage that it is more likely to be read completely. At the same time, because it is so short, the KDE report seems less corporate, an impression that is fitting for the project's more community-based orientation.
Beyond these general impressions, what is most interesting is the financial accounting in the reports. The two reports are not strictly comparable, given that many FOSS activities occur in the northern hemisphere's summer rather than spring. Nor is it always obvious in either report what falls under each line item. Still, some differences emerge.
For instance, GNOME lists an income of just over $102,000 for the quarter covered by its report. This income includes $65,000 from the Desktop Summit, $20,000 from "advisory board fees" (which I interpret mainly as donations from corporate sponsors), and $12,400 collected by the Friends of GNOME, a promotional and fund-raising project.
Omitting the Desktop Summit as a one-time source of income, these figures mean that GNOME has traditionally relied on corporate supporters. Corporate supporters continue to provide the bulk of GNOME's income, but the total from Friends of GNOME suggests that GNOME may be switching to a more community-based source of income. However, given that GNOME reported an approximate income of $54,000 per quarter in 2008 (http://markmail.org/message/bsk4gush6hoq42ef), GNOME does appear to be suffering from reduced income this year; if you divide the one-time Desktop Summit income over all quarters, GNOME is apparently operating this year on about $47,000 per quarter.
By contrast, KDE's income for the quarter covered by its report totaled just over $111,000 (if you convert the figures from Euros to approximate American dollars). This is actually an increase from the incomes of $93,000 and $102,000 in the fourth and second quarter of 2008. In other words, despite GNOME's wooing of corporate support, KDE appears to have roughly twice the budget of GNOME in each quarter. And, just as importantly, KDE does not seem to have been affected by the recession.
What is not altogether clear is where KDE's income is coming from. However, if you assume that the Camp KDE sponsorships and donations indicate corporate donations, then KDE is attracting more support from business than GNOME, Assuming that "supporting members" refers to individuals, KDE is also is collecting more than twice as much from indviduals.
To keep running, GNOME spends $34,401 on wages and $3300 on employee travel, while sponsoring the costs of developers traveling to the desktop summit with $10,300. No other travel expenses are listed, so, presumably, GNOME spends a comparable amount for travel each quarter.
In comparison, KDE spends $17,000 on wages, plus some $2000 for legal expenses and $3,000 for board meetings -- presumably because a number of board members travel from North America to attend. Even so, its administrative costs are less than half GNOME's, despite its larger income.
Moreover, KDE also provides some $27,000 in travel expenses to events ranging from developer meetings, conferences and Camp KDE, a total well over twice that of GNOME, even in a quarter without the Desktop Summit. From these figures, it appears that KDE places a far greater emphasis on face to face meetings than GNOME currently does.
Considering these figures, you should not be surprised that KDE was reporting a positive balance of over $288,000. GNOME's total balance was not reported, but, considering that last year GNOME was expecting a short fall of some $40,000, the chances are that its bank balance is nowhere near KDE's.
These suppositions might change if we knew exactly what each line item involved. Still, the differences are consistent enough to make clear that KDE is more than holding its own in the corporate world. What's more, it appears to run more cheaply than GNOME, and to spend more of its money on its community.
These conclusions are no reflection on GNOME, nor on the current members of the GNOME Foundation. If nothing else, being centered in North America, GNOME might have been harder hit by the recent recession than KDE, which tends to be centered in Europe.
But these conclusions do show how your impressions can change when you get to the bottom line. KDE, from what I can see, is not the underdog that many imagine.
Comments
comments powered by DisqusSubscribe to our Linux Newsletters
Find Linux and Open Source Jobs
Subscribe to our ADMIN Newsletters
Support Our Work
Linux Magazine content is made possible with support from readers like you. Please consider contributing when you’ve found an article to be beneficial.
News
-
ESET Discovers New Linux Malware
WolfsBane is an all-in-one malware that has hit the Linux operating system and includes a dropper, a launcher, and a backdoor.
-
New Linux Kernel Patch Allows Forcing a CPU Mitigation
Even when CPU mitigations can consume precious CPU cycles, it might not be a bad idea to allow users to enable them, even if your machine isn't vulnerable.
-
Red Hat Enterprise Linux 9.5 Released
Notify your friends, loved ones, and colleagues that the latest version of RHEL is available with plenty of enhancements.
-
Linux Sees Massive Performance Increase from a Single Line of Code
With one line of code, Intel was able to increase the performance of the Linux kernel by 4,000 percent.
-
Fedora KDE Approved as an Official Spin
If you prefer the Plasma desktop environment and the Fedora distribution, you're in luck because there's now an official spin that is listed on the same level as the Fedora Workstation edition.
-
New Steam Client Ups the Ante for Linux
The latest release from Steam has some pretty cool tricks up its sleeve.
-
Gnome OS Transitioning Toward a General-Purpose Distro
If you're looking for the perfectly vanilla take on the Gnome desktop, Gnome OS might be for you.
-
Fedora 41 Released with New Features
If you're a Fedora fan or just looking for a Linux distribution to help you migrate from Windows, Fedora 41 might be just the ticket.
-
AlmaLinux OS Kitten 10 Gives Power Users a Sneak Preview
If you're looking to kick the tires of AlmaLinux's upstream version, the developers have a purrfect solution.
-
Gnome 47.1 Released with a Few Fixes
The latest release of the Gnome desktop is all about fixing a few nagging issues and not about bringing new features into the mix.
Inward investment UK
i wanted to thank for this great read
<a href="http://www.locations4business.com/europe/uk/ ">Inward investment UK</a>
Thought
http://ezinearticles.com/?P...-Quick-and-Easy&id=3968251
My view
<a href="http://ezinearticles.com/?P...-Easy&id=3968251"> payday loans Canada</a>
cool
would you mind updating your blog with more information? http://www.pcgamesupply.com/buygames/Exteel-Online
travel
Th4t be an epic da shizzi4 post, th4nkie 4it & in da futures we'll be seeing more of it
We7ll I8be dat9 ogr6e speekie da speekie, gratz & than4x
heb7e sh8at be th34nkie 4it on da posting left & righ8ty
http://libertytravel.com
http://discountcruises.com
http://flightcenter.com
Flower store in uk
I really liked your article. Keep up the good work.
Flower store in uk
Hey great stuff, thank you for sharing this useful information and i will let know my friends as well.
Moroccan furniture
The Review given in this post is useful for us
My view
http://watchhotmoviesonline.com/
information
diamond jewelry
http://www.royaldesignonline.com/
My thanks
http://yeastinfectionscausesandtreatment.com/
My thought
I completely agree with you. I really like this article. It contains a lot of useful information. I can set up my new idea from this post. Thanks so much!
http://www.galapagos-bound.com/
spam filters
My view
http://www.peru-bound.com/
nice article
<a href=http://www.legendarydevils.com/>free full downloads</a>
my thoughts
<a href="http://theaccidentlawyers.org/injury-lawyer/">injury lawyer</a>
It is not to be forgotten that Nokia j
Regards, capatana,
http://www.highdesign.ro
Good idea!~
http://www.aquavidapools.com/saltwater.php
GNOME
http://www.stagcleaningservices.co.uk
engagement rings
I found this article very interesting and informative. It will definitely add to our knowledge.
<a href="http://www.royaldesignonline.com/">engagement rings</a>
nfl jerseys
Great, lots of good advice on your post. and as a return,i will buy a <a href="http://www.stajump.com">NFL Jerseys </a>to you for my thanking.
it takes some time
http://www.ldevils.com
My thought
http://www.aquavidapools.com/poolplastering.php
Opinion
http://simulationassuranceauto.org
Well done !
http://www.locations4busine...ire/stevenage-borough-council/
My thought
The blog is absolutely fantastic. Lots of great information and inspiration, both of which we all need. Thanks.
http://www.tradefromhome.co.za/
Excellent post!
My thought
Sorry for mistakes
http://www.aboutdiet.net/ab...mend-ab-circle-for-perfect-abs
Hello there
<a href=http://www.aboutdiet.net/ab...b-circle-for-perfect-abs>ab circle pro reviews</a>
I always feel great
I always feel great when I find the blog useful for and it takes place in my collection. And, moreover, my colleagues are just fixed on it.
<a href="http://theaccidentlawyers.org/injury-lawyer/">injury lawyer</a>
great
http://placementargent.org
cool
I put a link to your blog at my site, hope you don't mind?
<a href="http://placementargent.org">placement argent</a>
Great work
Remikon
roman
Thanks for teaching me these. http://www.ultramadol.us/
siwon
In the game karos online, <a href="http://www.buygoagold.com/">goa gold</a> is very important, you do some task to improve your levels, and you can get the <a href="http://www.buygoagold.com/">gates of andaron gold</a>, playing the game with your friends ,you fight the monster together, in addition, you can <a href="http://www.buygoagold.com/">buy goa gold</a>, In order to <a href="http://www.buygoagold.com/">buy gates of andaron gold</a>, it is wealthy to spend time and money playing the game, Getting the <a href="http://www.buygoagold.com/">cheap goa gold</a> is effective and interesting.
Rapidshare Search Engines
there has been a great deal
American FTC against bloggers and web-site owners
for not publishing marketing revenue, or potential
relationships with marketing agencies.
<a href="http://www.hotwallpapers4u.com/">Hollywood Wallpapers</a>
What are your personal thoughts about how this could potentially effect
the blog community?
buy everquest 2 gold
SuSE
KDE vs Gnome
I switched because Linux can't edit video from my HD camera, and Mac is king in video editing. iWork, which is their office suite, while not free, its only $89 for Keynote (powerpoint replacement), Pages (word), and Numeric (spreadsheet).
KDE is not for me, as I can't stand a start bar. I love having the Mac, its polished. Software updates to the OS are tightly integrated into the GUI. In KDE/Gnome, software updating depends on the distribution, no smooth way to keep your system up to date through one interface.
The sad part about linux is, all the "open source" stuff I can run on the Mac, and the reasons to run it on Linux are pretty low. Would I give my grandmother linux, no? would I buy her a MacMini yes.
Mac is more expensive but, the software GarageBand, iTunes, iWork, far better than KDE or Gnome.
My guess is KDE and Gnome will fight each other for years to come, meanwhile, you can just buy
a mac and be over with the desktop wars. Linux community is stupid to even have KDE vs Gnome, there are some great Gnome apps like Gnumeric and AbiWord, why would you re-invent the wheel? but you did KDE has to have its own Kword... I remember using Krita it was garbage compared to Gimp.
I don't think Windows 7 or Apple's Snow Leopard has anything to fear from Linux. Even the netbooks started to dump Linux in favor of XP.
As time goes by I don't miss Linux and all the fights/desktop wars/kernel wars (remember Con Colivas?)
food for thought
GNOME-KDE
Interesting place to look for info.
Re: You have to look at the year
"To get an accurate picture of the finances, you have to look at the entire year. For example, most of GNOME's income comes in during the first two quarters of the year. (And you are correct. Most of the GNOME Foundation's donations have traditionally come from corporate sponsors and we have done a big drive this year to increase community contributions through Friends of GNOME. We've raised that from about $6,000 last year to over $20,000 this year. Interestingly, most financial donations come from users, not contributors.)
"Our budget is published on our website and our 2009 results will come out soon as our fiscal year ends September 30th. "
Stormy:
You're right, of course, that a whole year should be more accurate than a single quarter, especially when that quarter includes an unusual event like the Desktop Summit. Maybe I will take another look in more detail when the yearly report is released.
Re: bias
"Your article seems to hint that there is some dark, hidden secret about where KDE's income is coming from. I would equate KDE's "Donations" with "Friends of GNOME", both are equally anonymous."
If that hint can be read into what I wrote, I certainly didn't intend it. All I meant to indicate was that "donations" did not give much information about the source. It might be equivalent to "Friends of GNOME," but it is not nearly as specific as a source.
Re: Seasonalilty of donations
"While I don't dispute that GNOME couple possibly run a tighter ship, you have perhaps chosen the worst quarter possible to judge the relative merits of the projects - the quarter in which the Gran Canaria Desktop Summit happened."
Dave:
Thanks for providing more detail. But I should stress that I was not passing any judgment about the projects' merits, just seeing what the quarterly reports might show about how the projects spend their money and what their priorities might be.
Re: KDE world Map
But if GNOME were so US-bound and KDE were so Europe-bounded, why do the maps look almost like each other?
http://worldwide.kde.org/
http://live.gnome.org/GnomeWorldWide
Big FAIL for your theory, I'd guess.
Seasonality of donations
While I don't dispute that GNOME couple possibly run a tighter ship, you have perhaps chosen the worst quarter possible to judge the relative merits of the projects - the quarter in which the Gran Canaria Desktop Summit happened. KDE and GNOME have a revenue agreement for that conference, where any conference budget surplus will be shared. Each project spends that surplus as they wish on developer travel & accommodation costs. The GNOME Foundation took in money from some sponsors, and KDE eV took in money from others. That one-time cost & revenue source will iron out in the wash, but it will take several months for those accounts to be completely closed.
In addition, the GNOME Foundation advisory board (as you rightly point out, the principle revenue source of the GNOME Foundation) is invoiced en masse in January of the calendar year. Any advisory board payments arriving during the Summer are actually late payments - in the first half of the calendar year, everyone has typically paid their dues.
About the wage bill: The hiring of Stormy Peters as executive director is one year old. Stormy has already had some great successes, and these will continue. In some sense, the higher wage bill of the GNOME Foundation is an investment in the future success of the project.
It's worth pointing out, in addition, that the foundation chose to aim to spend some of its surplus on accountant's advice - as a non-profit he considered that we had too much reserves. From memory, I believe that our reserves are roughly the same as KDE eV's, around $250,000.
While you have a point, I feel that these bits of information undermine your argument somewhat. The reality is that the GNOME Foundation has an annual budget roughly equivalent to that of KDE eV, and chooses to spend it differently.
Gnome & Compiz
"After using a long line of Fedora versions and switching to Ubuntu with version 8.04, I finally decided to switch to KUbuntu version 9.04, why? Basically for only one reason: Compiz "Desktop Cube" does NOT work at all with GNOME and works quite well in KDE ..."
I'm using Gnome, and I have Compiz desktop cube working right now. Just the plain old square at the moment, although both cylinder and sphere work just as well.
I prefer Gnome because it's just a plain desktop without the flashiness of KDE. Even with Compiz working, which I sometimes use to show Windows users what they're missing, the desktop is suitably professional. You see, I use a computer as a tool, not as an end in itself. Gnome allows me to get my work done without being distracted by KDE's bling.
Simples.
GNOME, KDE Experience
bias
In the beginning...
And on the "true open source" argument I always found curious that the Miguel de Icaza was, in the beginning, such a zelot and now he is an evangelist for turning Microsoft's .NET platform, through Mono, the GUI platform of choice in Linux. And Gnome is increasingly moving towards Mono. Hurray for "true open source" wars.
KDE
one small omission
The rationale for such a comparison is that the readership/audience of anything to do with finance reports of the top 2 FOSS _Desktop_ projects will not be restricted to just Linux users.
Herein is very powerful argument for the hardy survival quality and undeniable longevity of GPLed software.
This is very much the best place to drive home to blockheads in Govts that the easiest way to make e-governance systems reliable, free, long-lasting and robust at nearly loose change cost is to base them on GPLed software.
Cathedrals are insanely expensive when compared with any kind of Bazaars.
Dont miss this quarterly opportunity.
It needs sufficient repetition to be noticed in the din of cloud marketing.
Re: KDE world Map
Not big deal
KDE world Map
The conclusion is that Linux with KDE/Gnome is most prominent in the Developed World where it really could benefit those in the Developing world more.
Seems like Money (cost) is not an issue, but that Free Time and general access to civil tech probably is.
(civil tech: electricity, telecoms..etc)
http://worldwide.kde.org/
And yes... KDE is no more European than Gnome, but I see why one can think so.
SuSE and Mandrake, the biggie European parents used KDE while Red Hat uses Gnome- the USA parent, as does Ubuntu - also now situated in North America. Debian, also from North America, traditionally *refused* to use KDE as Qt was not 'True Open Source'.
So there is validity in saying that:
KDE == European,
Gnome == North American
..based on *distro locality*...
The USER-BASE, is international though for both.
I heard
Just the word on the street though.
what is this?
Really scraping the bottom of the barrel.
Re: Too many assumptions
Too many assumptions
Hah
Go GNOME!
KDE / Qt
EU - US
http://commit-digest.org/ma...;standalone=no&expanded=no
You should not think of the foundation as the whole of the project
You have to look at the year
Our budget is published on our website and our 2009 results will come out soon as our fiscal year ends September 30th.
Europe & US